Determing the Key of Your Tracks + Labeling Conventions
Determing the Key of Your Tracks + Labeling Conventions
Great mixes are often the result of two complimentary tracks done in the same key, at the right point in each song. As I'm sure everyone knows, you can have a perfectly beatmatched mix that still sounds like garbage because the two songs are completely out of key.
So, that makes me wonder if anyone knows of good (or better yet, easy!) way of determining the key of your tracks.
Does anybody label, name, or group their tracks by key for their sets? Any good labeling methods to share?
And then finally, obviously not every track you play is going to be in the same key, so what is a good method for determining what keys you can mix into/from.
Yes, I know ultimately you need to trust your ears, but it would be nice to have a slightly more scientific or theoretical approach to compliment it.
So, that makes me wonder if anyone knows of good (or better yet, easy!) way of determining the key of your tracks.
Does anybody label, name, or group their tracks by key for their sets? Any good labeling methods to share?
And then finally, obviously not every track you play is going to be in the same key, so what is a good method for determining what keys you can mix into/from.
Yes, I know ultimately you need to trust your ears, but it would be nice to have a slightly more scientific or theoretical approach to compliment it.
only thing you can do is play scales and keys with the track till you find the right one, you'll get better and faster at it with time.
I found this and it's quite useful when trying to use more than one key.
http://www.andymilne.dial.pipex.com/Modulation.shtml
it works ALMOST all the time. try it out.
I found this and it's quite useful when trying to use more than one key.
http://www.andymilne.dial.pipex.com/Modulation.shtml
it works ALMOST all the time. try it out.
-
- Posts: 2054
- Joined: Sat Apr 30, 2005 4:05 pm
- Location: Stockholm, Sweden
There has been a few advertisments on the General forum for this software: http://www.mixedinkey.com/
It supposedly finds the key for most songs. There is a free trial.
It supposedly finds the key for most songs. There is a free trial.
I use a piece of software called Mixmeister to calculate the key and bpm of my music library. The software is designed for doing mixes, but it's pretty basic from that point of view - however the bpm and key ananlysis features are pretty good. It will automatically analyze your whole music library without having to select individual tracks. The results are usually pretty accurate, especially bpm, and it's easy enough to double check if the key is right once you've loaded it into ableton and listened to it alongside a synth playing that note.
I find it very usefull for planning mixes, as you can build playlists and quickly preview how 2 songs will sound together. You can also right click on any track and select "find similar" which will bring up a list of all the other tracks you have which are of a similar key and tempo. Saves a lot of time!
Unfortunately this software is PC only, which is the only reason i still have a pc. I run Mixmeister through remote desktop from my Apple G5. So if anyone knows of anything similar for the mac it would be good to know.
Glad to see more people are thinking about mixing in key, it's the way it should be done. I group all my tracks by key in ableton. I basically have 4 folders for rough tempo ranges (60-100bpm, 100-125bpm, 125-150bpm, and 150bpm+) and within each of these have a folder for each key. Be interested to hear how other people are doing it.
Peace out.
Rokko
I find it very usefull for planning mixes, as you can build playlists and quickly preview how 2 songs will sound together. You can also right click on any track and select "find similar" which will bring up a list of all the other tracks you have which are of a similar key and tempo. Saves a lot of time!
Unfortunately this software is PC only, which is the only reason i still have a pc. I run Mixmeister through remote desktop from my Apple G5. So if anyone knows of anything similar for the mac it would be good to know.
Glad to see more people are thinking about mixing in key, it's the way it should be done. I group all my tracks by key in ableton. I basically have 4 folders for rough tempo ranges (60-100bpm, 100-125bpm, 125-150bpm, and 150bpm+) and within each of these have a folder for each key. Be interested to hear how other people are doing it.
Peace out.
Rokko
camelot notation is a joke and a crutch for people who don't know what actual key signaures are.Grade E wrote:I just downloaded and used the mixedinkey software. The results are quite impressive, and the tutorial and "camelot sound" chart they provide to show keys that will be complimentary is far and away the easiest I've seen to use. Wow, this is a huge leap forward in my humble opinion.
dominant and subdominant harmonics are a hell of a lot easier than remembering those stupid numbers...maybe that's just 'cuz i'm a chior boy.
If only you, me and DEAD people could read hex, would we need this forum?
-
- Posts: 686
- Joined: Wed Dec 14, 2005 9:28 pm
- Location: NYC