Device that worked in beta not working in shipping build.

[synnack]

Hi all.

Now that M4L has officially shipped I'm going through the devices on maxforlive.com and confirming they work as expected on the shipping product.

So far I have found an issue with my LineFO device. Can someone else try this and confirm if this is a problem or just my machine?

You can grab the device here: http://www.maxforlive.com/library/device.php?id=66

If i load that device before an operator instance and hit "get devices" the list of devices does populate but the dropdown for list of parameters in that device does nothing. If I click edit button and lock the device it does actually work in the max patcher view, but not in the ableton device view.

Can anyone else confirm that to be the case on their machine that has the shipping build on it already?

[synnack]

Ugh. this is driving me nuts.

I have 2 laptops. One with 8.1b10 and this this device works fine on that one.

The other with 8.1 installed today M4L.api.SelectParameter doesn't work in Ableton view, only in the max view.

EDIT: Ok so I put message boxes to show the output of both MFL.api.SelectDevice and MFL.api.SelectParameter and added them to presentation view.

In beta build, the message boxes show [id 8] for example, looks fine.

In shipping build, the message box for MFL.api.SelectDevice shows [id id] in the device, but in Max patcher window it shows [id 8] like it should.

[synnack]

I know i'm talking to myself but anyway...

So i created a new and braindead simple patch to test. just a bang to a bpatcher with M4L.api.SelectDevice and a message box to show the output.

Low and behold, that works fine.

Then I loaded my original device into a new set, and what do you know, that works fine too now.

So randomly it broke, and randomly works again.

yay early adopter!

Now onto playing with all the default content...

[olivierseb]

In shipping build, the message box for MFL.api.SelectDevice shows (id id) in the device, but in Max patcher window it shows (id like it should.

the more I use m4l the more I think this "id" prefix for right inlets is a pain, would be easier to just send the integer to this input.

I guess it is there for future features to send to this right plug.... maybe.

I stop moaning now and enjoy the release

[Ralf]

I know i'm talking to myself but anyway...

That's a misperception.

Let me know if you should have that "id id" problem again.

[synnack]

Thank you Ralf.

Another user has reported the exact same behavior as a comment on the device shown at the bottom of this page:

http://www.maxforlive.com/library/device.php?id=66


It is still working as expected for me but it appears for him it did the same thing. weird.

[Ralf]

Another user has reported the exact same behavior ....

I have testet that LiveFO patch, could not reproduce the "id id" issue.
But I've added an assertion to the debug version of the software,
so we'll see it if it happens again.

Ralf

[Parametex]

Hi,

I'm able to get the above patch working in M4L on Mac but not on my PC ...

Cheers,

[Ralf]

Hi,

I'm able to get the above patch working in M4L on Mac but not on my PC ...

Cheers,

What does it look like? Any printouts in the Max Window (->context menu of device title bar).

Thanks,
Ralf

[olivierseb]

Hi,

I'm able to get the above patch working in M4L on Mac but not on my PC ...

Cheers,

What does it look like? Any printouts in the Max Window (->context menu of device title bar).

Thanks,
Ralf

great tip Ralf !

Thanks a lot

olivier

[synnack]

Hi,

I'm able to get the above patch working in M4L on Mac but not on my PC ...

Cheers,

I uploaded a slight update today. It uses a few live.menu's instead of unmenu's per Ralf's suggestion and now has number boxes so you an midi map min/max ranges to a controller.

Give that one a try and see if the behavior is any different.

Still working for me on both my Mac and PC.

http://www.maxforlive.com/library/device.php?id=66

[Parametex]

Hi,

I wasn't able to check the max window errors yet ... Monday I hopes ... If anyone has a PC and a lil' time in the weekend please test the patch out.

Cheers,

[stringbot]

I downloaded the patch today and found the same behavior - the device menu populates but the parameter menu does not in Live, but in Max everything seems to work as it should. I'm on a Mac.

[Ralf]

I downloaded the patch today and found the same behavior - the device menu populates but the parameter menu does not in Live, but in Max everything seems to work as it should. I'm on a Mac.

You clicked the refresh button, then choose a device, but the parameter menu stays empty. Did I understand that right?

Ralf

[stringbot]

You clicked the refresh button, then choose a device, but the parameter menu stays empty. Did I understand that right?

Correct.

But if I hit the "edit" button and choose an item from the "device" menu in the Max programming environment, the parameter menu populates as expected.