Page 1 of 3

The *cost* of the EIC...?

Posted: Fri Jul 21, 2006 10:19 am
by headquest
I just read this statement in the Ableton press release about the SONiVOX partnership:
Ableton press release wrote:An initial set of multi-sampled instruments will ship free with Live 6 with additional Expansion Sound Sets to be released in the near future.
I also note from the LIve 6 upgrade pricing information that the difference in price between the Live 5 online vs. boxed upgrade is (as it has been for ages) $30. But that the price difference between the download and boxed upgrades for Live 6 will rise to a far more significant $100.

Given that Ableton are a truthful company I am assuming that the EIC is indeed free, but wonder what is included new in the Live 6 box (not in the Live 5 box, and not the core program) that accounts for the $70 extra charge?

Also I am interested to know about the "additional Expansion Sound Sets" that Ableton plan to market "in the near future" - can anyone advise how much will these cost?

THis information is obviously critical in terms of deciding whether to go for the download or boxed upgrade, and indeed whether to invest in Sampler as well.

THANKS in advance :D

Posted: Fri Jul 21, 2006 10:27 am
by glitchrock-buddha
I am curious about weather you get the EIC for free if you buy sampler. I can't imagine a sampler where you have to pay an additional 100$ for the library, but from what I gather on the site, it seems to look this way (boxed upgrade vs. download).

I intend to order the download update, but I want to buy sampler. I have no problem with the $200 price, but I sure as hell would expect the library to be included. I'm uncertain if this is the case though. Perhaps someone from Ableton could comment?

thanks,

grb

Posted: Fri Jul 21, 2006 10:31 am
by headquest
glitchrock-buddha wrote: I can't imagine a sampler where you have to pay an additional 100$ for the library, but from what I gather on the site, it seems to look this way (boxed upgrade vs. download).
True enough, but the point is the EIC is actually FREE in the box according to Ableton. That's why I am curious to know what the $100 pays for... :?

Yes, hopefully somebody can answer these questions please :D

Posted: Fri Jul 21, 2006 10:33 am
by dazzer
Headquest - great question. i noticed it too in the newsletter which seemed to contradict what I'd read. Interested to hear the answer.

Posted: Fri Jul 21, 2006 10:39 am
by glitchrock-buddha
I think they mean it's free when you buy it new (in the box), but if you're upgrading, it's an extra $100 to get EIC (and manuals i guess), which is the difference.

But I think if you still have to pay the extra $100 to get the EIC when buying the sampler, that would be an extremely low-blow. No doubt EIC should come with sampler.

We'll have to see...

grb

Posted: Fri Jul 21, 2006 10:43 am
by headquest
No, there's still a $100 difference between online/boxed for brand new customers of Live 6, as opposed to the usual $30 difference for new customers of Live 5.

This sudden $70 increase affects everyone - both new customers and upgraders. That is why I am wondering what is included new, given that the EIC is free...

Re: The *cost* of the EIC...?

Posted: Fri Jul 21, 2006 10:45 am
by hoffman2k
headquest wrote:I just read this statement in the Ableton press release about the SONiVOX partnership:
Ableton press release wrote:An initial set of multi-sampled instruments will ship free with Live 6 with additional Expansion Sound Sets to be released in the near future.
I also note from the LIve 6 upgrade pricing information that the difference in price between the Live 5 online vs. boxed upgrade is (as it has been for ages) $30. But that the price difference between the download and boxed upgrades for Live 6 will rise to a far more significant $100.

Given that Ableton are a truthful company I am assuming that the EIC is indeed free, but wonder what is included new in the Live 6 box (not in the Live 5 box, and not the core program) that accounts for the $70 extra charge?

Also I am interested to know about the "additional Expansion Sound Sets" that Ableton plan to market "in the near future" - can anyone advise how much will these cost?

THis information is obviously critical in terms of deciding whether to go for the download or boxed upgrade, and indeed whether to invest in Sampler as well.

THANKS in advance :D
The sonivox and EIC are 2 different things...
I can't point out the difference, but there's probably a reason why the sonivox thing is in a different section of the press statement.

You pay extra for the box, because it contains the EIC collection.
The sonivox stuff will probably be available as download.

At least thats how I understand it.

Posted: Fri Jul 21, 2006 10:51 am
by Angstrom
I want a boxed upgrade but not the EIC .
a shame they don't offer that option, because I don't really want to buy a collection of things I've not heard!

My experience of sample sets is -"one man's meat is another man's poison"

Posted: Fri Jul 21, 2006 10:51 am
by headquest
So the free "initial set of multisampled instruments" from sonivox is NOT the EIC? :?

I'm still a little confused I'm afraid, so perhaps you can help more...

Robert Henke has already explained that the EIC multisamples can be loaded into Simpler for playback, but according to s.balm (Ableton), other multisamples can't.

So do you know - or can anybody else comment - whether the sonivox multisampled instruments can be loaded into Simpler, or will I need Sampler to use these free multisampled instruments?

Thanks in advance... 8)

Posted: Fri Jul 21, 2006 10:56 am
by glitchrock-buddha
So if you buy sampler, you don't get the EIC, but you get some other library showing off it's features?

Posted: Fri Jul 21, 2006 11:08 am
by hoffman2k
headquest wrote:So the free "initial set of multisampled instruments" from sonivox is NOT the EIC? :?

I'm still a little confused I'm afraid, so perhaps you can help more...

Robert Henke has already explained that the EIC multisamples can be loaded into Simpler for playback, but according to s.balm (Ableton), other multisamples can't.

So do you know - or can anybody else comment - whether the sonivox multisampled instruments can be loaded into Simpler, or will I need Sampler to use these free multisampled instruments?

Thanks in advance... 8)
Honestly, I'm confused too.
Lets just say that the marketing dept. made a booboo.
I'll see if i can get this cleared up, because i've read a lot of different things by a lot of different people.

@angstrom

There was a time when you couldn't order the manual, but they adjusted to that.
If there's actually a demand for the box + manual, they'll probably supply.

Posted: Fri Jul 21, 2006 11:11 am
by headquest
Thanks hoffman2k - I appreciate your help clearing this up and look forward to hearing back from you if you have an answer later. 8)

Cheers.

Re: The *cost* of the EIC...?

Posted: Fri Jul 21, 2006 12:34 pm
by diverdee
hoffman2k wrote:
headquest wrote:I just read this statement in the Ableton press release about the SONiVOX partnership:
Ableton press release wrote:An initial set of multi-sampled instruments will ship free with Live 6 with additional Expansion Sound Sets to be released in the near future.
I also note from the LIve 6 upgrade pricing information that the difference in price between the Live 5 online vs. boxed upgrade is (as it has been for ages) $30. But that the price difference between the download and boxed upgrades for Live 6 will rise to a far more significant $100.

Given that Ableton are a truthful company I am assuming that the EIC is indeed free, but wonder what is included new in the Live 6 box (not in the Live 5 box, and not the core program) that accounts for the $70 extra charge?

Also I am interested to know about the "additional Expansion Sound Sets" that Ableton plan to market "in the near future" - can anyone advise how much will these cost?

THis information is obviously critical in terms of deciding whether to go for the download or boxed upgrade, and indeed whether to invest in Sampler as well.

THANKS in advance :D
The sonivox and EIC are 2 different things...
I can't point out the difference, but there's probably a reason why the sonivox thing is in a different section of the press statement.

You pay extra for the box, because it contains the EIC collection.
The sonivox stuff will probably be available as download.

At least thats how I understand it.
The ostensibly 'free' EIC is made by Sonivox (sonic implants) according to info. on this site, they aren't different things - it's just product (EIC) & product manufacture (sonivox).
If the box now costs $70 more & one pays 'extra for the box, because it contains the EIC collection' - how can the EIC then be claimed to be free?
It is obviously another $70 charge on top of the cost of sampler ($200) if one wants some content fro the sampler.
Furthermore, judging from the very limited articulations for the strings it appears to be just a 'taster' set of sonivox's samples.

Re: The *cost* of the EIC...?

Posted: Fri Jul 21, 2006 12:42 pm
by hoffman2k
diverdee wrote:
hoffman2k wrote:
headquest wrote:I just read this statement in the Ableton press release about the SONiVOX partnership:
I also note from the LIve 6 upgrade pricing information that the difference in price between the Live 5 online vs. boxed upgrade is (as it has been for ages) $30. But that the price difference between the download and boxed upgrades for Live 6 will rise to a far more significant $100.

Given that Ableton are a truthful company I am assuming that the EIC is indeed free, but wonder what is included new in the Live 6 box (not in the Live 5 box, and not the core program) that accounts for the $70 extra charge?

Also I am interested to know about the "additional Expansion Sound Sets" that Ableton plan to market "in the near future" - can anyone advise how much will these cost?

THis information is obviously critical in terms of deciding whether to go for the download or boxed upgrade, and indeed whether to invest in Sampler as well.

THANKS in advance :D
The sonivox and EIC are 2 different things...
I can't point out the difference, but there's probably a reason why the sonivox thing is in a different section of the press statement.

You pay extra for the box, because it contains the EIC collection.
The sonivox stuff will probably be available as download.

At least thats how I understand it.
The ostensibly 'free' EIC is made by Sonivox (sonic implants) according to info. on this site, they aren't different things - it's just product (EIC) & product manufacture (sonivox).
If the box now costs $70 more & one pays 'extra for the box, because it contains the EIC collection' - how can the EIC then be claimed to be free?
It is obviously another $70 charge on top of the cost of sampler ($200) if one wants some content fro the sampler.
Furthermore, judging from the very limited articulations for the strings it appears to be just a 'taster' set of sonivox's samples.
You see, the thing is. I've heard claims that the EIC library is for SIMPLER and would be compatible with SAMPLER.
In live 6 it's perfectly possible to make multi-instrument racks with SIMPLER.
While that would actually be harder with SAMPLER when it comes to instrument ensembles.

Posted: Fri Jul 21, 2006 12:55 pm
by diverdee
Only actually editable with sampler though, if i'm correct -although it's obviously too early yet & a lot of this is speculation.
What isn't speculation though is the obvious $70 boxed set price wise (that's like over 200%!!!) when the only diiference seems to be that the boxed set contains an ostensibly 'free' sampleset.
Don't get me wrong, i'm not trying to be overly negative - I like Live, but that's the kind of thing that will quickly atract negative publicity & it looks bad, & htat's on top of another couple of niggles regarding pricing & live isntrument host compatability (or the lack therof) i.e. operator & sampler itself.